History of Key Lime Pie

A Taste Of The Keys

Many years ago Ponce de Leon searched the Florida Keys for a hidden treasure only to leave empty handed. In an ambitious effort to fulfill this ancient quest we uncovered the finest treasure the Florida Keys had to offer. These sweet treats are meticulously handcrafted and redefine the idea of dessert. Each Key lime pie slice or bite is covered in a rich cocoa coating and served hassle free for a perfect treat any time of the day. We welcome you to kickback, relax, and enjoy the fruits of our bounty.

History of the Key Lime Pie

Though the exact origin of the key lime pie is debatable, it is known that the Key Lime Pie dates back to the early 1800’s. Where it is said that creative sponge fishermen, without refrigeration on their boats, were limited to non perishable food that included key lime pie ingredients: key limes, canned milk, sugar, crackers and eggs. Without ovens about their boats the pie was furthermore not baked. The fishermen relied on the natural thickening of the proteins when mixed with the acidic lime juice. Without the concern of uncooked eggs, rather using fresh cream from Florida,Island Pie Shoppe follows these traditions in the production of our Key Lime Pie products.

The Florida Key Lime

The Key Lime, also called Mexican Lime or West Indian Lime was likely introduced to Florida by the Spanish in the 1500’s. Due to destructive hurricanes and difficult growing conditions in Florida the small yellowish green Florida Key Lime, as we know it today, is mostly found on the trees of Florida backyard gardeners never reaching the grocery store. The majority of Key Lime is now imported from various tropical regions of the world.

if you have any questions or would like to place an order, please call us! 888-784-3929

We ship every Tuesday!

Where To Buy

Look for us in BJ’s! Soon you will be able to order directly online, but in the meantime, please fill out the form below,
or call us to place an order.888-784-3929

if you have any questions or would like to place an order, please call us! 888-784-3929

We ship every Tuesday!